Clemente (9/10)
by Tony Medley
105 minutes.
Directed by David Altrogge and written by Elise
Andert & Altrogge, this is an exceptional documentary that focuses more
on the man than his exploits on the field, although it includes shots of
his performances. He was an outstanding player but a better human being.
Roberto Clemente, long time rightfielder for the
Pittsburgh Pirates in the mid-20th Century, was a great
athlete. He ran the 100 meters, the 200 meters, the 400 meters and even
threw the javelin, 175 feet the first time he tried it and the Puerto
Rican record was 205.
Although he signed with the Dodgers in 1955, they
put him in Montreal because they were the best team in baseball and
didn’t have room for him on the roster. But he rarely played in Montreal
because he wasn’t protected and the Dodgers did not want to lose him in
the draft.
Branch Ricky was the general manager of the Dodgers
at the time and was the one who signed him. However, Dodgers owner
Walter O'Malley forced Ricky out and Ricky became the general manager of
the Pittsburgh Pirates. The Pirates had a terrible team so they got the
first pick in the draft and Rickey knew all about Clemente and drafted
him. That meant Roberto had to live in Pittsburgh which was an
industrial town. He was discriminated against because he was not white,
but he was not considered black, either. He was Puerto Rican, so he was
alone.
Even though he spoke English fluently, he did not
let on that he was bilingual. When someone asked him why he did not
speak English, he responded that it was a way for him to listen to
people talking about him in English and find out how they felt about
him.
When asked by an interviewer if his manner is such
that he seems unapproachable, he answered, “I don’t like a lot of
writers. This is something that I don’t want to deny. And I tell you why
I don’t like lots of writers. They put the interview in a way that it
sounds like you have said that when you don’t say exactly that.”
When the Pirates won the World Series over the
Yankees in 1960, he was 8th in the balloting for MVP. His
teammate, Dick Groat won MVP. He didn’t begrudge Groat the award, but
was hurt that he was so low in the voting.
He said, “I love people. And I love people that
they are not big shots I like common people. I like workers. I like
people that suffer.”
Manny Sanguillén, who became a teammate several
years after Roberto joined the Pirates, said, “He was like a big
brother. He taught me everything at that time. The first year that I got
there, 1966, He said, ‘if you need anything let me know I'm here to help
you.’… He loved all the poor people because he knows how much they
suffer…. He said, ‘Manny I was looking for a friend for a long time.
Thank god that you came because I’ve been here by myself. Really alone.
I didn't have anybody to talk to. I don't have anybody to go eat with. I
don't have anything. I was a lonely person. I want you to be my friend
because I respect the way you live your life.’
“I've never seen him go to any strip joint or any
dive bar. Because he said, ‘Manny, I have to represent the Latinos good
because someday there's going to be a lot of Latinos playing in the big
leagues. I Have to be the leader for all the Latinos’. That's the kind
of guy Roberto was.”
It also tells about his tragic death and how it
could have been averted with more attention to detail. The plane in
which he crashed was in horrible condition and the pilot was
unqualified, to say the least.
I saw Clemente play his first year in the majors
and many, many times after that. Willie Mays gets all the press, but
Clemente was his equal. He had a higher lifetime batting average than
Willie (.317 v. .302), won more batting titles (four for Roberto vs. one
for Willie) and a better arm (as good as any outfielder, ever), and had
more outfield assists than Willie (266 vs. 188). Despite all this,
Willie is consistently referred to by many as the greatest player of his
era, if not of all time and nobody ever mentions Roberto. Even Dodgers’
legendary announcer Vin Scully called Mays the best player he ever saw
without a mention of Roberto. I think there is a strong argument that
Roberto was better than Willie.
However, this film shows and emphasizes what an
outstanding human being he was, and that’s what sets it apart from (and
above) other documentaries about athletes.
|