J. T. LeRoy (7/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 108 minutes.
R.
In the early 21st
Century a writer name Laura Albert wrote Sarah, an apparently
first person, autobiographical account of a homosexual male inflicted
with HIV named J.T. LeRoy and his struggle with life. She got her
sister-in-law Savannah Knoop to be the avatar of LeRoy and together for
six years they pulled the wool over the eyes of the public who read the
book (I not only never read it, I never heard of it and, frankly,
couldn’t care less).
Directed by Justin Kelly from a
script by him and Knoop, based on her book GirlBoyGirl, Laura
Dern plays Laura and Kristen Stewart is Savannah, this is a creepy
androgynous film that I found off-putting. Laura is an upbeat,
enthusiastic mover who encourages Savannah to play J.T. For her part,
Savannah seems always reluctant.
I guess everything would have
been all right if Laura had just written a straight novel. But since she
represented the book as the true story of a real person she found
herself in the bind to present that real person. What we see on the
screen is a relatively believable story of how she did it and how the
two of them carried it off. Not much is said about the dishonesty
involved, nor about the damage done by those who believed in the
veracity of the book, only to find out it was a sham from the outset.
The film takes the story from
when Savannah and Laura meet and carries it through to the denouement,
as they eventually get involved in making a movie about J. T.
So it was all news to me. The
film is well done and does hold interest, especially if you are new to
the tale. But it is creepy, especially the lesbian scenes between
Savannah (as J.T.) and Eva (Diane Kruger), who is an actress producing
the film about J.T. I was never clear whether or not Eva knew that J.T.
was really a woman while they are making out and having sex.
While Dern’s performance is
annoying, maybe that’s what she’s supposed to be. Stewart gives a
believable performance assuming that Savannah really was going along
against her better instincts. Since they did it for six years, though,
that’s a little hard to swallow. And she has made a career out of what
she did. In the end it basically whitewashes what she/they did that was
blatantly dishonest and reprehensible. But this film does tell the
story, if you're interested.
|